Fraudulent misrepresentation and director liability – when advance payment is demanded shortly before insolvency

The Camper Base case and what those affected can do personally against those responsible.

Anyone demanding payment despite knowing they can no longer deliver may be held personally liable. This is the crucial lever when the insolvency estate is depleted. Rogert & Ulbrich examines the prerequisites and coordinates criminal charges and civil enforcement against management.

The Camper Base case: a documented pattern

The insolvency of the motorhome dealer Camper Base Rhein-Main The pattern discussed in this article becomes particularly evident in the summer of 2024. The following description is based on publicly available reports, especially from Hessischer Rundfunk (Hessian Broadcasting).

The sequence of events according to these reports:

  • Insolvency application at the end of July 2024The company filed for insolvency at the end of July 2024. According to the findings in the proceedings, the insolvency had already existed weeks earlier.
  • Payments until the very endNevertheless, customer payments continued to be accepted. In one reported case, a customer transferred a five-figure sum a few days before the proceedings began, after pressure had been exerted to make the payment.
  • Documents without vehicleSome customers received vehicle registration documents, but never the vehicle itself. Following the reporting, one affected individual had spent a high five-figure sum on a motorhome, selling his house to finance it, without receiving either the vehicle or the documents.
  • InvestigationsThe Darmstadt public prosecutor's office was investigating on suspicion of delaying insolvency proceedings; in addition, private individuals filed criminal charges for fraud. At the time of reporting, the investigations were in their early stages.

Important context: This concerns suspected wrongdoing and an ongoing investigation, or one that was ongoing at the time of reporting. Only the criminal courts can decide on criminal liability. However, for those affected, even the suspicion itself is reason enough to examine the civil liability of those responsible, as this is not dependent on a criminal conviction.

Therefore, examine not only what happened to the company, but also who acted on its behalf and when.

Fraudulent inducement: when advance payment can become a criminal offense

The term "fraudulent inducement" describes a specific form of fraud under Section 263 of the German Criminal Code (StGB). The damage does not occur only upon non-delivery, but rather upon conclusion of the contract: The buyer acquires a claim that is economically worthless from the outset because the contractual partner cannot or will not perform.

Four points are crucial for the exam:

  • illusionThe ability and willingness to perform are misrepresented. This can also include concealing an existing insolvency, when this should have been disclosed.
  • Error and disposition of assetsThe customer pays because they trust in the delivery. Payment is the disposition.
  • DamageThe damage lies in the difference in value between the amount paid and the counterclaim, which was devalued from the outset. The fact that a small portion may be paid later does not eliminate the damage.
  • Intent at the time of the actionThe crucial point is what the individuals involved knew at the time of concluding the contract or requesting payment. This is the most difficult aspect, and it is established through circumstantial evidence.

Typical indicators in practice include the time relationship between the payment request and the insolvency application, pressure for quick payment, changed payment methods, promises of delivery dates that were technically no longer feasible, and internal knowledge of supplier terminations or blocked credit lines.

Therefore, save everything that documents the date and content of the payment request. These documents are crucial for proving intent.

Delaying insolvency proceedings and the liability of management

Besides the fraud charge, there is a second set of issues, which is often more practical because it has lower requirements. According to Section 15a of the German Insolvency Code (InsO), the management of a GmbH (limited liability company) must file for insolvency without undue delay in the event of insolvency or over-indebtedness, and at the latest within the maximum time limits specified therein. If this application is filed late, it constitutes a delay in insolvency proceedings, which is a criminal offense under Section 15a Paragraph 4 of the InsO.

Under civil law, this entails personal liability. The obligation to file for insolvency under Section 15a of the German Insolvency Code (InsO) is understood as a provision intended to protect creditors as well. Therefore, anyone who concludes a contract and accepts payment after the obligation to file has arisen can be held personally liable for damages under Section 823 Paragraph 2 of the German Civil Code (BGB) in conjunction with Section 15a of the German Insolvency Code (InsO).

A distinction must be made between two groups of creditors, which determines the amount of the claim:

  • New believerAnyone who only entered into a contract and made payment after the obligation to file for insolvency arose would not have entered into the contract at all had the delay not occurred. This group can, in principle, claim full compensation for reliance damages, i.e., the amount paid, and not just the difference in the quota.
  • Old BelieversThose who were already contractual partners are limited to the so-called quota damage, i.e., the reduction in their quota due to the delay. This damage is significantly more difficult to quantify.

For buyers who ordered and paid shortly before the insolvency application, this is the economically crucial distinction. They regularly belong to the group of new creditors.

Therefore, clarify the point in time at which the obligation to apply arises. This will determine whether you can claim the full amount or only a pro rata difference.

Sources of information: legal proceedings, expert opinions, creditors' meeting

The point in time when insolvency occurs is key to the entire claim, and it is not initially apparent from the outside. However, documents are generated during the insolvency proceedings themselves that contain precisely this information.

  • Expert opinion of the provisional administratorIt regularly comments on the point at which insolvency occurs. This finding is central to the question of liability.
  • Reporting date and creditors' meetingThe administrator will report on the causes and progress of the case. As a registered creditor, you have the right to attend. Following the reporting, a creditors' meeting was scheduled for December in the Camper Base case, which affected customers intended to attend.
  • Access to filesAs a party to the proceedings, you can request access to the insolvency file under the legal conditions.
  • Criminal proceedingsAs a victim of a crime, you have the option of requesting access to the investigation file through a lawyer. This file often contains documents that prove the perpetrators' level of knowledge.
  • Commercial RegisterThis reveals who was the managing director at the relevant time and whether there were any changes. Even a de facto managing director without being officially registered can be held liable.

Therefore, be sure to report your claim. to the table Register, even if you don't expect a quota. Registration grants access to information and event dates.

Properly integrating criminal charges and civil proceedings

Filing a criminal complaint and a civil lawsuit serve different purposes. Criminal proceedings aim to prosecute the crime, not to secure compensation. However, if the order of these actions is correct, they can significantly strengthen your civil case.

  • Use of the displayThe public prosecutor's office has investigative powers that are not available to you. The resulting file is often the only realistic source for proving intent.
  • Limits of the displayFiling a complaint does not lead to payment. Even a discontinuation of proceedings does not mean that civil liability is excluded, as the standards differ.
  • Preliminary voteA poorly worded complaint can warn the accused and shape one's own version of events before the evidence is known. Therefore, it should be legally reviewed beforehand.
  • No threatThe threat of criminal charges must not be used to coerce payment. This can itself have legal consequences.
  • Statute of limitations in viewTort claims for damages are subject to the standard limitation period under Sections 195 and 199 of the German Civil Code (BGB), which begins to run when the claimant becomes aware of the damage and the liable party. The commencement of the limitation period can therefore be linked to the knowledge gained from the expert report prepared by the administrator.

Plan your legal action and civil proceedings together, not separately. We have discussed further recovery options after a provider's insolvency in our article. Camping provider insolvent We have compiled information on claims arising from fraudulent activity and address them on our website. Online fraud.

What is realistically achievable: enforcement and insurance coverage

A claim against a private individual is only worth as much as it can be enforced against that individual. This question should be asked at the beginning, not the end, because it determines whether the effort is worthwhile.

These aspects need to be examined:

  • Directors' and officers' liability insuranceMany companies maintain directors' and officers' liability insurance, often referred to as D&O insurance. This covers claims arising from breaches of duty by management and is directed against a solvent insurer. However, intentional acts are typically excluded from coverage, which is why the grounds for a claim must be carefully considered.
  • Several people responsibleIf there were multiple managing directors, they are regularly jointly and severally liable. This increases the chance of finding assets belonging to at least one person.
  • Prospects of enforcementBefore filing a lawsuit, it should be assessed whether assets are available. Indications can be found in the land register, commercial register, and findings from insolvency proceedings.
  • Titles in stockEven if there's currently nothing to be gained, a judgment can be useful. According to § 197 of the German Civil Code (BGB), it only expires after thirty years and can be enforced later.
  • No discharge of residual debt in cases of intentIf insolvency proceedings are conducted against a natural person, claims arising from intentionally committed torts are not covered by the discharge of residual debt under Section 302 of the German Insolvency Code (InsO) if they were duly declared during the registration process. Therefore, correct registration is crucial.

Have the enforceability of your claim assessed before initiating legal proceedings. A claim without any prospect of enforcement can still be worthwhile, but this should be a conscious decision. You can find further articles on vehicle disputes in our section. Automotive.

Rogert & Ulbrich – Your lawyers when dealing with advance payments shortly before insolvency

Rogert & Ulbrich represents consumers nationwide at the intersection of civil law, insolvency law, and criminal law. Attorneys Dr. Marco Rogert and Tobias Ulbrich and their team combine civil enforcement with criminal law expertise and are familiar with the evidentiary requirements in cases of intent and liability against managing directors.

We will review your documents to determine if you belong to the group of new creditors and, through procedural documents and file review, ascertain the date on which the obligation to file a claim arose. We will register your claim in the schedule of claims, safeguard your rights to information during the proceedings, and enforce claims against those responsible personally. We will coordinate any criminal charges with the civil law strategy beforehand. If an out-of-court settlement cannot be reached, we will also represent you in court proceedings.

Did you make an advance payment shortly before the insolvency? Contact us without obligation and have the personal liability of those responsible reviewed.

FAQs – Frequently Asked Questions about fraudulent misrepresentation and director liability