Online car sales fraud
hire a lawyer now
Online car sales fraud: Scams and legal help for sellers
Selling your car online allows you to offer it quickly, conveniently, and to a wide audience. Digital car marketplaces, classifieds portals, and social networks facilitate contact, expedite transactions, and promise a good price. At the same time, selling a car online is among the riskiest legal transactions on the internet. Scammers exploit the lack of personal oversight, fictitious payment methods, and manipulated identities to financially harm private and commercial sellers. Anyone wanting to sell a vehicle online should be aware of the most common and modern scams. The shipping company scam, fabricated claims for damages, the reverse of advance payment scams, contract tricks, the "window card" scam, counterfeit money, and the price-cutting scam are among the most dangerous risks in online car sales.
Many sellers only contact a lawyer after the vehicle has already been handed over, but the purchase price is not paid or additional claims are subsequently made. Even in these cases, legal action is advisable, as there are often still ways to secure claims or limit damages.
Enforce legal claims in just 3 steps
Simple, convenient & fast – we enforce your rights.
commissioning
Give us your mandate easily and conveniently via online form from home.
1lawsuit & trial
We will take care of all the remaining steps for you. Sit back and relax.
2Success
We will successfully enforce your claim and you can enjoy the success immediately.
3The advance payment trap in sales: When apparent payment security conceals fraud
The advance payment trap is a common form of car sales fraud, not only when buying but also when selling. At first glance, the prospective buyer seems legitimate. They contact you quickly, show strong interest in purchasing, and are willing to pay the asking price or even more. As the seller, you receive alleged payment confirmations via email, screenshots of bank transfers, or letters supposedly from banks. The buyer insists that you hand over the vehicle and its documents immediately because the payment is "on its way.".
In reality, no final credit has yet been received in your account. The supposed payment confirmations are forged or merely transfer orders that were never executed or were later reversed. Once you have handed over the vehicle, the buyer disappears without a trace. The money never arrives, and your vehicle is gone.
Legally, fraud occurs if the buyer deliberately deceives you about the existence of a payment, you hand over the vehicle in reliance on a guaranteed return, and thereby suffer a financial loss. Handing over the vehicle without verifiable, final credit to your account is one of the biggest risks in online car sales.
Even if the vehicle has already been handed over, those affected should not assume the case is lost. A swift legal review can clarify payment methods, communication histories, and potential recourse options.
We will take care of your case – quickly & with commitment.
The shipping company trick: A new scam in car sales with an international flair
The so-called "shipping company trick" is one of the most modern and dangerous scams in online car sales. The buyer claims to be abroad or unable to appear in person due to work commitments. They offer to have the vehicle picked up by a shipping company. Often, they cite international export, diplomatic duties, or special professional roles to gain the buyer's trust.
The scam involves fake emails from supposed shipping companies, fictitious pickup orders, and deceptively realistic websites designed to give the impression of a reputable logistics firm. In some cases, sellers are even asked to advance alleged transport or insurance fees, which are supposedly later deducted from the purchase price. In another variation, everything is allegedly already paid for, the shipping company is about to pick up the vehicle, and you only need to hand over the vehicle and documents because the driver "can't wait" otherwise.
In reality, the shipping company often doesn't exist or is involved in the scam. Once the vehicle has been handed over, it disappears, either domestically or abroad, making legal recourse difficult. In many cases, the seller is left without a vehicle and without receiving the purchase price. Legally, this is a form of fraud that exploits geographical distance and a seemingly professional process to trick you into handing over the vehicle.
Especially with the shipping company scam, time is a crucial factor. The sooner legal help is sought, the greater the chances of securing evidence and initiating possible legal action.
Fictitious claims for damages: Pressure after the sale
A particularly insidious scam involves fabricated claims for damages following a seemingly legitimate sale. Initially, the online car sale proceeds without incident. The purchase agreement and handover take place, and the purchase price is paid. Only later does the buyer contact the seller, claiming that the vehicle is defective, has undisclosed accident damage, the engine is faulty, or the mileage has been tampered with.
Often, purported repair reports, cost estimates, or photos of damage are presented, which are either exaggerated or staged. The buyer demands substantial price reductions, additional payments, or threatens cancellation of the contract, legal action, and criminal charges. The aim is to put you, the seller, under pressure, even though there is no fraudulent misrepresentation and no objectively significant defect.
Legally, such claims for damages are only justified if there is actually a material defect as defined by the German Civil Code (BGB) that was present at the time of delivery and was not disclosed. In private sales, liability for material defects is often effectively excluded, unless you have fraudulently concealed defects. Fictitious claims without solid evidence therefore generally do not provide a basis for claims. In extreme cases, the line may be crossed into attempted extortion or coercion. In any case, you should not make any payments without having the allegations legally reviewed.
Threats of lawsuits or criminal charges are a typical form of coercion. Legal advice can quickly clarify the situation and protect against hasty, unnecessary payments.
Contract tricks in sales: When wording is used to your disadvantage
Contract tricks are a popular tool used by unscrupulous parties in both buying and selling. Online car sales often involve the presentation of pre-made contract templates that appear legitimate at first glance, but in reality contain clauses specifically designed to disadvantage you. These include unclear mileage regulations, hidden assurances of accident-free status, unusual liability agreements, or clauses that impose obligations on you beyond what is legally required.
Particularly problematic are formulations that could subsequently give rise to claims by the buyer. For example, if the contract stipulates the characteristic "accident-free" from the buyer's perspective, even though you only stated "no known accidents," this could later be interpreted as an alleged warranty. Conversely, unclear or incomplete information can lead to accusations of fraudulent misrepresentation, even if there was no intent to deceive.
Legally speaking, a written purchase agreement forms the crucial basis for the rights and obligations of both parties. If false or ambiguous information is included, this can lead to significant disadvantages in the event of a dispute. Do not allow yourself to be pressured into spontaneous contract changes and do not sign anything you do not fully understand. If in doubt, contracts should be reviewed by a lawyer before signing, especially if the buyer uses their own templates or demands unusual clauses.
Window card scam – quick cash deals with high risk
The "window card" scam is increasingly playing a role online as well, with dubious "buyers" operating simultaneously on internet platforms and on the street. Typically, a note with the message "We buy your car – cash payment immediately" is left on the vehicle. If the seller contacts them, a supposed dealer appears who promises a quick transaction but shows little interest in a proper contract.
The often-described tactic involves initially offering an attractive price and then drastically reducing it during negotiations. Alleged damage, extensive repair needs, or supposed market conditions are cited. Sometimes, attempts are made to take the vehicle while the actual payment remains unclear. In other cases, a small down payment is made, but the remaining balance is deferred to a later date without adequate security.
Even if such cases don't always constitute criminal fraud, they are legally very risky. Without a clear, written sales contract, without full payment, and without verifiable buyer information, you risk permanently losing your vehicle or selling it significantly below its value. The more opaque the situation, the higher the risk that the transaction will escalate into car sales fraud.
Counterfeit money: When the purchase price only appears genuine at first glance.
When selling a car for cash, there is a risk that the buyer will use counterfeit money. Especially with older vehicles or when a quick sale is desired, a large sum of cash is often paid directly upon handover. Fraudsters mix counterfeit bills with genuine ones or pay the entire purchase price in counterfeit money. They rely on the seller not carefully checking the authenticity under time pressure.
If it later turns out, usually during the bank deposit, that the money is counterfeit, the damage is considerable. The vehicle has been definitively transferred, and the purchase price is effectively worthless. Banks retain counterfeit money and do not replace it. For the unsuspecting seller, this means a complete financial loss. Under criminal law, the use of counterfeit money is a serious offense, but even a conviction does not automatically lead to financial compensation.
Cash payments made at a bank, where the authenticity of the banknotes is immediately verified, are safer. Alternatively, a real-time bank transfer is an option, the receipt of which you can monitor in your online banking. If the buyer insists on cash payment at any location and refuses to have the banknotes checked together, extreme caution is advised.
Price-cutting trick: Subsequent negotiations at the seller's expense.
The price-cutting trick is a frequently underestimated scam in car sales. Buyer and seller initially agree on a specific purchase price. At or shortly before the handover, the buyer then begins to bring up alleged new defects, such as engine noises, paint damage, or supposed leaks. Referring to these "new findings," he suddenly demands a drastic reduction in the agreed purchase price.
Many sellers have already turned down other potential buyers, initiated organizational steps, or mentally prepared themselves for payment by this point. This psychological pressure is deliberately exploited to enforce a lower price at short notice. Although this is not always illegal, it can constitute fraud in individual cases if deliberately false claims are made to induce you to accept an unwanted price change.
Legally, the decisive factor is the purchase price stipulated in the final contract. Therefore, do not allow yourself to be pressured into making spontaneous handwritten changes without reconsidering your position. If alleged defects are brought up that were not previously discussed, you can interrupt the sales process, obtain an expert opinion, or terminate negotiations. A reputable buyer will openly communicate any legitimate concerns and give you time to review the matter, rather than exerting undue pressure.
Why fraud is so easy when selling cars online
Online car sales often take place under time pressure, remotely, and without personal connection. Potential buyers can operate anonymously, using disposable email addresses and masked phone numbers, and contact numerous sellers within a very short time. Professionally crafted messages, seemingly legitimate payment confirmations, and the appearance of international business models can lead private sellers in particular to a false sense of security.
Furthermore, many sellers are insufficiently informed about the legal intricacies of sales contract law, liability for defects, and the burden of proof. Contractual tricks, fictitious claims, and fabricated legal arguments appear convincing at first glance. This interplay of information asymmetry, digital anonymity, and psychological pressure creates an environment in which fraud in car sales is particularly easy.
How to effectively protect yourself as a seller from fraudulent schemes when selling cars online.
The most important protection is to retain control of the vehicle and its documents until the purchase price has been fully and verifiably received. You should not make any advance payments, accept vehicle handover before final payment, or use complicated payment methods or escrow arrangements with unknown service providers.
It is advisable to clearly verify the buyer's identity by checking a valid ID card and comparing it with the contract details. Draw up a written purchase agreement that fully and unambiguously records the vehicle details, any known defects, and the final purchase price. Refuse to sign any clauses you do not understand at short notice.
Exercise particular caution with buyers who communicate exclusively via messenger services, provide evasive information, use foreign bank accounts, or want to use shipping companies without a prior in-person inspection. Anyone trying to pressure you into acting quickly rarely has your best interests at heart. If in doubt, seek legal advice before finalizing the transaction.
The aforementioned protective measures are also relevant even if the sale has already taken place. They form the basis for the legal assessment of whether fraud, deception, or unjustified claims have occurred.
Support from our law firm – legal security when selling cars online
If you suspect a potential buyer is acting dishonestly, or if you have already fallen victim to one of the described scams, you shouldn't wait until the situation worsens. Our law firm reviews purchase agreements, payment methods, communication histories, and vehicle handovers to determine whether fraud, deception, or unjustified claims have occurred.
We support you in enforcing your rights, for example by rescinding the purchase agreement, asserting claims for damages, or defending against unjustified claims for damages. We also assist you with filing criminal charges and communicating with the police, public prosecutor's office, and insurance companies. Early intervention significantly increases the chances of limiting or avoiding financial losses.
Professional advice & support
We offer you a professional and comprehensive initial consultation regarding car fraud. Take advantage of this opportunity and avoid mistakes.
Frequently asked questions about
Online car sales fraud
Didn't find the right answer?
Write your question to
office@ru.law
or call us:
+49 (0)211 / 819770
We are available for you 24/7.
